Church of Ireland split over gay rights and DUP's conscience clause Bill

I am reprinting an article which appeared in the Belfast Telegraph on March 4th, 2015 about the proposed ‘conscience clause’ being introduced into Stormont.  What I find interesting is the rhetoric being used by both the politicians and the church in favour of this clause.  In November 2010, The Daily Telegraph published a letter from religious leaders urging the then Labour government to reconsider the lowering of the agent of consent.  It was signed by 17 signatories, including the former Archbishop of Canterbury, George Carey and Cormac Murphy-O’Connor, head of the Roman Catholic Church and the secretary general of Muslim Council of Great Britain.

The letter stressed strong ‘moral’ objections to the lowering of the age of homosexual consent: that it brought alleged health risks, and ran counter to “the beliefs of many religious people – Christians, Jews, Muslims, Hindus,” and that the legislation was contrary to public opinion.
To accept this ‘conscience clause’ is to accept a step back to the days where we had no rights.  I honestly urge you to write to your councillors, MPs, Stormont representatives and tell them that this clause is wrong.
The Stop the Clause petition had more than 148,000 people who have signed the petition against the Northern Ireland DUP-backed “conscience clause” bill that would permit anti-gay discrimination.



Church of Ireland split over gay rights and DUP’s conscience clause Bill

Canon Charles Kenny, left, and Rev Adrian DorrianCanon Charles Kenny, left, and Rev Adrian Dorrian
Canon Charles Kenny, left, and Rev Adrian Dorrian


A split has opened in the Church of Ireland over its attitude to the DUP’s ‘conscience clause’.

An article in tomorrow’s Church of Ireland Gazette newspaper has sparked off an angry reaction from a pro-LGBT pressure group.

In the article, the Rev Adrian Dorrian, chairman of the Church and Society Commission, said he broadly welcomed the Bill introduced by the DUP’s Paul Givan.

If passed, the Lagan Valley MLA’s Private Members Bill would allow those with strongly-held religious beliefs to refuse to provide certain services.

Mr Dorrian said he would seek amendments to the bill to “ensure it cannot be used to facilitate discrimination against members of the LGBT community”.

The Bill was introduced by Mr Givan after the Equality Commission took legal action against Asher’s Bakery over its refusal to make a cake with a message promoting gay marriage.

Rev Dorrian said: “We will certainly encourage a comprehensive conversation around religious and civil freedom in Northern Ireland and I will be affirming the Church of Ireland’s position that marriage ‘is part of God’s creation and a holy mystery in which one man and one woman become one flesh’.”

However, Canon Charles Kenny from the Church of Ireland’s gay rights group Changing Attitude Ireland said Rev Dorrian’s views may not be representative.

The Church of Ireland did not make a formal written response to a consultation process on the bill which ended last Friday.

Rev Kenny said: “I hope that the Rev Dorrian’s view is not shared by all members of the Commission or the wider membership of the Church of Ireland.”

“This is more Mr Dorrian’s views, as he’s known as a social conservative, rather than the views of the Church and Society Commission as they have not put out any official response to the DUP over the consultation.

“He seems to be making this an issue between gay people on one hand and Christians on the other.

“And it’s not. There are lots and lots of members who do not accept the hardline, fundamentalist, biblical literalistic line that Mr Givan and the DUP has as a whole.”

He said that he was dismayed at the anti-gay motivation and tone of the DUP’s conscience clause but was heartened by the nearly quarter of a million signatories to an online petition against it.

Last night Mr Dorrian confirmed that the Church and Society Commission had yet not met to discuss its official response, although he and several other Commission members met Mr Givan yesterday.

He said: “With regard to the Ashers Bakery cake I think the vast majority of Christians seem to think that there is mismatch between the Ashers case in relation to the charges being brought against the bakery and what actually happened. The Church of Ireland is very clear that there can be no room for discrimination, but that doesn’t mean that there can’t be a disagreement about how to interpret the morality of such things.”

In 2012, the church’s Synod voted to reaffirm its support of traditional marriage between a man and a woman.

2 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply